Router Access Control List to prevent users from using alternate DNS

Thank you to anyone that takes the time to read this, I have an ac750 archer c2 router and I am using OpenDNS. I have set the DNS for the WAN to OpenDNS's servers and I'm trying to follow their instructions on ALLOW TCP/UDP IN/OUT to 208.67.222.222 or 208.67.220.220 on Port 53 and BLOCK TCP/UDP IN/OUT all IP addresses on Port 53. I've added the host as the whole range of ip's availabe (192.168.1.0 - 192.168.1.199) on port 53 and named it "All" and the target is OpenDNS's server #1 (208.67.222.222) named "OpenDNS1". I'm just focusing on getting one working right, then I'll add the second. Then for the schedule I have selected all the time available 24/7.

Here is the table in the router control list now:

 Description:   LAN Host:   Target:     Schedule:   Rule:   Status: 
Allow DNS IN    Any Host    OpenDNS1    Any Time    Allow   Enabled 
Allow DNS out   Any Host    OpenDNS1    Any Time    Allow   Enabled 
all in            All       Any Host    Any Time    Deny    Enabled 
all out           All       Any Host    Any Time    Deny    Enabled 

I've played around with the rules a ton, at one point I had it so I could use the OpenDNS server if my PC was set to auto set the DNS, but if I change it to google's DNS of 8.8.8.8 then it bypasses the OpenDNS and shows adult content and stuff that I don't want. I had ipv6 on before and I was getting weird results, then when I turned ipv6 off it was working as long as I didn't change the DNS.

I've been flushing the DNS Resolver Cache via ipconfig /flushdns, but that doesn't seem to help. I can get a little impatient when trying different rules out, should I try resetting the router/each device after I change the rules? Or will it be near instant like I'm hoping?

My end goal is to only have 2 devices that are allowed to bypass the OpenDNS and use their own/google's DNS.

Thanks for the help!